​
​OVERALL GRADE: C+ 

• Performance: C
• Price: B
• Quality: C
• Innovation: C

Walla Walla, WA
51°F
Sunny
Wind W 8 mph Humidity 54% Dew Point 40°F Pressure 29.97 in 
Visibility 10.0 mi UV Index 3 of 10

The Coldpruf Platinum Crew and Pants are okay.  Our review showed them to be adequate for warmth and durability, but oversized compared to similar next to skin layers.  The fit is baggy (oversized) and uncomfortable if layered for a long period of wear.  We also found the sleeves to be cut too short to stay fully down the wrist.  The pants are comfortable, but not as a layered piece.  We feel that the posted pictures are misleading for the actual fit of the garment.  The wool is not as soft/comfortable as competitive items.  The price for the both the crew and top is very competitive-low.  Overall, you get what you pay for; a functional unremarkable base layer.      

​OVERALL GRADE: A- 

• Performance: A
• Price: C
• Quality: A
• Innovation: A

This is an incredibly warm and light base layer.  It was a cold day at Crater Lake with a modest wind.  The Patagonia Merino  Air felt comfortable and shockingly warm. The two reportable downsides are that the unconventional 'merino air' fabric has a foreign waffle feel, and that it is very expensive.  It appears to be durable, but the jury is out until is survives an entire season of real wear.  From a warmth, weight, and aesthetic point of view, this is a wonderful base layer, nearly living up to the considerable hype from Patagonia.  Overall, a highly recommended base layer with a steep price.    
​